I’m just gonna say it: the clean girl makeup trend is way harder to pull off than it looks on TikTok. Like, I thought it was gonna be a five-minute “dab some concealer, brush some brows, done” kind of vibe. Nope. My first attempt looked like I’d just run a mile in humid subway air—not cute.
If you’re sitting there like, “Girl, same,” then hi. Welcome. Grab your iced oat latte and pull up a chair. Because I’ve been through the trial-and-error phase (some of it horrifying, some of it kinda funny), and I’ve learned what not to do when trying to achieve that effortless-but-actually-strategic clean girl look.
And I’m not gatekeeping. Not after what I went through.
Mistake #1: Thinking “Clean” Means “No Makeup”
Listen, I fell for this too. “Clean” sounds like “bare,” right? Like, minimalist, maybe a tinted moisturizer and chapstick? Ha. HA. The clean girl makeup trend isn’t about wearing less makeup—it’s about looking like you’re wearing less makeup. Big difference.
I remember my first attempt—bare face, a little powder, some gloss. My coworker literally asked me if I was “feeling okay.” (Cue internal screaming.) Meanwhile, the actual clean girl look is all about strategic concealing, subtle contouring, and blending everything until your arms hurt.
Mistake #2: Skipping Skincare Because “Makeup Will Fix It”
The clean girl aesthetic is like building a house—you can’t throw marble countertops on a crumbling foundation. Same with makeup. I used to slap on concealer over dry patches, thinking it’d “blur” them. Spoiler: it highlighted every flake.
I’m talking cleansed, moisturized, SPF’d skin. (Yes, SPF even in winter, even when you’re in Queens running from the 7 train to your bodega for a bagel.) Your skin has to look like skin before the makeup. Otherwise, no amount of Glossier Stretch Concealer is gonna save you.
Pro tip I learned from a random TikTok at 1 a.m.: mix a drop of your favorite face oil with your foundation. It’s like cheating, but legal.
Mistake #3: Over-Baking and Over-Powdering
I get it. We’ve all been traumatized by mid-day T-zone shine. But nothing ruins a clean girl makeup look faster than heavy powder. The whole vibe is dewy, fresh, alive. Not “I just walked out of a matte desert.”
I once baked under my eyes for so long I legit forgot about it while scrolling on my phone. By the time I brushed it off, I looked like a reverse raccoon. The clean girl trend is more about cream products—cream blush, cream bronzer, liquid highlighter. Powders are like, the side dish, not the main course.
Mistake #4: Ignoring Brows
Oh my god, the brows. This is where the magic happens. The clean girl makeup trend is basically sponsored by brushed-up, fluffy brows.
I used to over-pluck back in high school (it was 2009, don’t @ me). Now, I’m in brow rehab. I thought brushing them a little with an old mascara wand was enough—nah. You need a good brow gel (clear or tinted), and you need to actually brush them up, not sideways. I swear it makes your whole face look more “done” even when nothing else is.
Bonus tip: Don’t use too much product. Once I went overboard with a tinted brow gel and ended up looking like Bert from Sesame Street. My best friend was like, “Girl… no.”
Mistake #5: The Wrong Shade of Blush
Blush is tricky. You can’t just grab the first pink you see. I learned this the hard way with a neon coral blush that looked gorgeous in the pan but clownish on my face.
Clean girl blush is like a whisper, not a scream. Think muted pinks, dusty roses, peachy tones. And placement matters—dab on the high points of your cheeks and blend toward the temples for that lifted look.
Side tangent: I saw this girl on the M train the other day who had the most perfect clean girl makeup. Blush was on point. I almost asked her what she used but chickened out (classic me).
Mistake #6: Too Much Highlighter
We all love a glow, but the clean girl makeup trend glow is strategic. Not disco-ball. Not “I fell in glitter.”
The key? Cream highlighter on the tops of your cheekbones, maybe the bridge of your nose, a touch on your eyelids. Done. Overdo it and you’re shiny in all the wrong places. Once, I tried that glazed donut vibe and ended up looking like I hadn’t washed my face.
Mistake #7: Forgetting Lips (Or Going Too Bold)
Clean girl lips are like… your lips but hydrated. No harsh lines, no intense matte shades. More like tinted balm, gloss, or a nude that’s actually your nude (not the one influencers call nude but looks beige on you).
True story: I wore a deep berry lipstick one morning with my clean girl base. Thought I was giving “effortlessly chic.” My coworker said I looked “very fall wedding guest.” In May. Lesson learned.
Mistake #8: Not Letting It Look Lived In
This is maybe the biggest one. The clean girl makeup trend isn’t about being perfect—it’s about looking like you just woke up hydrated, stretched, did a 10-step skincare routine, and had a green juice. If you blend every line until your face looks like a mannequin? You’ve lost the plot.
Sometimes leaving a little imperfection—a freckle showing through, a soft edge on your eyeliner—actually makes it look more authentic.
My Personal “Clean Girl” Routine (When I Actually Get It Right)
Because let’s be real—sometimes you just need a step-by-step to copy.
- Skin prep: Cleanse, moisturize, SPF, dab of face oil.
- Base: Lightweight skin tint, concealer under eyes only where needed.
- Brows: Clear gel, brush up, whisper of pencil.
- Blush: Cream blush high on cheeks.
- Highlight: Cream highlighter, tiny amount.
- Lips: Tinted balm, done.
- Mascara: One coat, nothing dramatic.
That’s it. Takes me 10 minutes on a good day, 15 if my kids are screaming in the background because we’re out of milk.
Outbound Links
- Glossier’s blog post on natural-looking makeup — because they basically invented the “no-makeup makeup” vibe.
- This hilarious TikTok account where people show their “clean girl fails” — you’ll feel seen.
. Here’s what not to do.” you really know about it."){kind=link}